
By R.C. Goodwin
Stiff as sentries, they sat in a booth at The Great Wall, a small windowless Szechuan place that had seen better days. Susannah, in her forties, presented a study in strong solid colors: maroon blouse, dark gray skirt and jacket, jet black hair. Her only jewelry was a wedding band. Jill, in her twenties, wore designer jeans, a yellow flowered shirt, and blue Cardigan; she sported a gold bracelet and four rings.
An elderly Chinese waiter took their orders. “Lemon chicken,” said Susannah, her voice clipped, “and Chivas on the rocks.”
“That sounds fine okay,” said Jill, indifferent. “And a glass of Chablis, please.” When the waiter shuffled off, Susannah spoke first. “I must say, this is a new experience for me. Having lunch with someone I’ve had thoughts of killing.”
Jill’s eyes widened. “I don’t think anyone has wanted to kill me before. How did you plan to do it?”
“I didn’t plan it, I just had passing fantasies about it. Nothing elaborate. Crushing your skull with a tire iron, say. His too, of course.”
“What kept you from it?”
Susannah shook her head dismissively, as if the question wasn’t worth a proper answer. “Because I didn’t want to lose my freedom over such a silly trifle. Because I’ve learned to weigh actions in terms of their consequences. Unlike you and him.”
“He was important to me from the first,” Jill responded, blushing. “As a mentor and then a friend. As someone I could talk to about anything, someone I felt I’d known for years instead of months. Whatever we had going, it was more than a trifle.”
She broke off as the waiter creaked towards them with their drinks, and resumed. “We weren’t as callous as you might assume. I never liked the idea of seeing a married man. Until we met, I’d never have considered it. But then I took his seminar, we worked together on my dissertation, and he —”
“— made you feel like the most special woman in the world?”
Jill nodded.
Susannah swigged down half the Scotch. “He does that brilliantly . . . he listens to you, drinking in what you say, looking into you with those piercing green eyes, and you feel like the center of the universe. His universe.” She stirred the Chivas. “I don’t know if he works at it or if it’s just an inborn talent.”
“Whichever, it’s effective. There’s more, though. He’s still young, but old enough to have seen and done a lot. His fellowships, his books, his political involvement. I’ve known a slew of boys but here was a real live grownup.”
“Debatable.”
They finished their drinks. Susannah summoned the waiter— “Another round.”
“How did you find out?” asked Jill.
“An extra movie stub. I was doing the laundry, going through the pockets. And there they were, two stubs. It clicked immediately. All those late nights at the library. His general distraction. His insomnia, that especially. As a rule, he sleeps like a hibernating bear. ‘You’re having an affair,’ I said. He didn’t try denying it. Truth is, I think he was relieved. Deceit and lying don’t come naturally to him, I’ll give him that.”
Toying with the empty glass, she continued. “‘Jill’s the best graduate student I’ve ever had.’ It wasn’t just what he said but how he said it . . . the lilting impassioned voice. And you stopped coming to the house with his other disciples. Strange, I thought, the favorite student disappears. Well, it makes more sense now.”
“I’m not a good actress. If I kept coming over, you’d have known for sure.” Jill paused. “Besides, it would have pretty sleazy. Eating your food, drinking your liquor, while I—”
“— slept with him,” Susannah finished the sentence.
The waiter brought their entrees, a pot of tea, and more drinks. They picked idly at their food.
“What did you really think would happen?” asked Susannah a few moments later. “That he’d leave me? That I’d kick him out?”
“I had no illusions we’d last forever. I knew he wouldn’t leave you. He spoke of you too fondly. Married men come on to me all the time, they try to paint their wives as jerks or bitches. He wasn’t that way at all. He took pride in your work too. Your books and lectures, your reviews. He considered you the best film critic in the business. But I admit, I sometimes wondered what life would be like with him. If we could start fresh after I got my Ph.D. Go to the West Coast, write books together, start a family. I knew it wasn’t likely, but I couldn’t let go of it.”
She stared at a point beyond Susannah’s shoulder. “I also knew that if you did find out, he’d have to choose between us, and I knew he’d choose you. So I hung on to our time together and tried to be grateful for it. But sometimes I got greedy, I wanted more. At times I even had some passing thoughts of killing you.”
Susannah raised her eyebrows. “Hmm. Here we are, two women who’ve wanted to kill each other, having a civilized lunch together, as genteel as a pair of nuns. Hitchcock could have done great things with that. Slipping cyanide into each other’s drinks, perhaps.”
“Does he know we’re meeting?”
“I didn’t tell him, but I doubt he’d like it much. It would go against his controlling grain.” Susannah shrugged. “Or else, he might be flattered. Sometimes he’s as predictable as turkey on Thanksgiving, and sometimes he surprises me no end.”
Jill poured herself tea. “I never thought he was predictable. That was one of the things I liked most about him. I never knew if he’d be quiet or expansive, if he’d talk about history or tell a joke. If he’d be aloof or tender. He could be the most tender man I’ve known—”
“Back off, sister! You’re talking about my husband!” Susannah threw out the words like poisoned darts.
“I’m sorry.” Jill lowered her eyes
“I wonder, are you really?”
“Yes. I’m sorry I hurt you, especially since you’ve done nothing to hurt me. I’m sorry for everyone’s sake, including my own, that I let this get so out of hand. But it’s hard to say I’m sorry the whole thing happened. Being with him, however briefly . . .” She left the sentence hanging.
They tried to resume eating, with small success. Then Jill looked across the table quizzically. “Why did you want to meet like this?”
Susannah considered. “Oh, for several reasons. Because I’d built you up as somewhat larger than life. Brilliant, beautiful and all that. I needed to see you in more human terms. Because I needed to know what happened from your vantage point, I wanted a sense of how you felt about him. And I wanted to let you know how I felt about him.”
“How do you?”
“You really don’t know? I love him, of course. If I didn’t, I would have left that first night, or asked him to leave.” She stopped to massage her forehead. “I’ll admit, the temptation to kick him out was considerable . . . still is, at times. Really, it’s such a cliché, ageing professor clings to youth by taking up with a student. I loathe clichés, I always have.”
“I won’t try to defend what we did, but it went beyond clichés.”
“That depends on your perspective.” Susannah fiddled with a chopstick. “Apart from my still loving him, I also let him stay because we have a history. Almost thirty years. Christ, we met as teens! The places we lived! Our first apartment, in Brooklyn, with the bed that sagged like a V unless we slept diagonally. Did he ever tell you about it? Our idea of a splurge was a weekend at the Jersey shore. His fellowship year at Cambridge. We flew there on what must have been the last prop charter flight across the Atlantic. Seventeen hours, including two on the ground in Newfoundland while they fixed an engine. How I took film courses and wrote reviews for The Village Voice while he finished his thesis. God, the way we worked, the way we dreamed! The graduate students were all in the same boat, and the boat was a leaky old tub, but we were close. We still are, a lot of us. We send each other Christmas and birthday cards, we get together when we can. We had fun, and we survived.”
“You’ll survive this too.”
“I know.”
The waiter cleared their dishes, still with considerable food on them. He refilled their teacups, and brought them fortune cookies. Susannah opened hers first and put on her glasses. “Love is a two-edged sword,” she read aloud. “How profound. Timely, though. What does yours say?”
Jill opened hers and laughed curtly. “It says the same thing.”
* * *
R.C. Goodwin has had thirteen short stories published in Center, Elixer, Northwest, and Writer’s Digest Online. among other publications. Three have won literary competitions; two others were included in anthologies. His debut book, THE STEPHEN HAWKING DEATH ROW FAN CLUB, a prison-centric collection of short fiction, was published in 2015. His novel, MODEL CHILD, a psychological thriller, was published in 2018. In 2023 his short story collection, THE MONSTER’S GIRLFRIEND, was shortlisted for the Acacia Fiction Prize of the Kallisto Gaia Press. His current project is a memoir, MAKING GOD LAUGH. The title comes from a proverb: “Do you know how to make God laugh? Tell Him your plans.”