
By Kerry McKay
In ninth grade, four-eyed Gina decided to become popular. She studied and emulated Dani and friends. She straightened her hair like them, wore earrings and slinky tops she’d stolen from the mall, rehearsed conversations and facial expressions in front of the bathroom mirror, and memorized dozens of song lyrics. Sure, she gave up her number-two singles position on the high school tennis team to make time for these social studies, but by tenth grade she had a boyfriend and Dani.
#
Twelve years later, Gina brought Maurits, whom she had met the week before, to Dani and Scott’s engagement party. After introducing Maurits and his pole-shaped body and bushy eyebrows to Dani, Gina followed Dani through the restaurant and called after her, “He’s only a date.” But blue-eyed Dani, in her white, off-shoulder sculptured mini dress and white Manolo pumps, leaned into Gina and whispered, “I bet he does magic with those plump lips.”
Maurits, who sat at the bar sipping red wine, suddenly looked desirable.
After Dani and Scott married, Gina equated being single with standing alone on the shore of a deserted island. A potential husband would be a rescue boat. But, should she climb aboard the first to arrive, even if it were a tugboat with a wheezing engine and peeling paint? Or should she hold off in case a yacht anchored in a year or two?
The morning Gina married a tugboat, she asked Dani, “Do you think Maurits is good looking?”
“Sure!”
Gina watched Dani’s reflection in the mirror as she zipped her gown. “But do you think we would’ve liked him in high school?”
Dani looked up and tilted her head.
They laughed and posed for selfies Gina posted on Facebook.
#
Since she was still childless, Gina volunteered to travel again for her and Dani’s biannual BFF visit. Maurits waved goodbye from their front stoop and then continued reading his poetry book as she started her engine.
Three hours later, Scott hollered “Hey, Good Looking!” from his BMW idling beside the train platform. “Dani’s feeding the baby, so I’m your chauffeur.” Scott had a dimple and perfect teeth.
The car’s interior was warm and smelled new. The heated seat relaxed Gina and, after a short highway ride, aroused her. She nearly leaned over and put her mouth in Scott’s lap. It wouldn’t have been the first time. She’d been with Scott in high school. They–Dani’s popular crowd that is–had all been with one another. Sometimes at the same time.
Over the next few days at Dani’s, Gina discovered an unexpected interest in diaper genies, homemade baby food, and breast pumps. On their last night together, after sharing a bottle of pinot grigio, Gina’s emotional elisions caught up with her. She should’ve been more honest with herself before she had married Maurits. She was better than him. Prettier. Popular in high school. A medical assistant, practically a doctor. She blurted, “I don’t love Maurits.”
Dani held Gina’s shoulders at arm’s distance. “You just need to have a baby.”
#
From the train station, Gina drove straight to Franklin Middle School. Her heels clicked down the locker-lined hallway. Telling her husband that she wanted a baby felt urgent. She was already sixteen months behind Dani. Teachers’ voices spilled out into the hallways. At his desk, in the corner of an empty classroom, under fluorescent lights, Maurits looked pensive, perhaps thinking of fatherhood.
Gina walked up to him.
“This is a surprise.” He stood and fetched a chair for Gina. One of the tennis balls, sliced open to act as a silencer, slipped off the chair’s foot and wobbled toward Gina’s royal blue Manolos. “When did you get back?”
Gina pushed her straightened brown hair behind one ear. “Just now.”
A waifish Asian girl and a lanky white girl appear at the classroom door. “May we borrow tape, Mr. Smythe?” they ask in chorus.
“Excuse us,” Gina scolded.
The girls giggled nervously and left with Maurits’s tape dispenser.
Maurits took a deep breath. “There’s a lot to catch up on.”
Gina nodded.
He rotated his chair to face Gina, sat up straighter, and put his palms on his skinny thighs.
“I’m not sure where to begin.” He rubbed his clean-shaven chin. “I’ve told a few colleagues this story. You should know too.”
An invisible slender needle pierced Gina’s neck.
Maurits continued in his baritone voice, “I befriended a waitress at Mario’s. She’s been serving me at my regular table.”
A new cheap gold-colored watch looked bulky on Maurits’s thin wrist. “Bibi lives in a small apartment with her little boy she had when she was sixteen.” He looked out the window.
Gina picked invisible lint off her slacks trying not to get impatient with Maurtis’s tendency toward idealism.
“She’s from Guyana. Her uncle took her here to America after her mother died.” Maurits saluted the flag with his coffee mug. “Her life could be a novel.”
Gina visualized a map of the world and placed this Bibi–who was likely short, overweight, and missing teeth–somewhere near Africa. “You’re gullible, Maurits. We’re not donating to a Go Fund Me for her. We’re going to need it for–.” She reached out, briefly squeezed his hand.
Maurits crossed his long legs. “She’s very pretty. Her skin is gorgeous. Some nights at Mario’s men and even couples invite her home.”
“Maurits,” she blushed, “are you suggesting we take her home?”
He held up a notepad and shook his head. “I write her love poems. We spent Monday at the Shore.” Now words spewed out of him like sewage. “I called in sick. Gina, I can’t take it anymore, all this sneaking around.”
The bell rang. Kids flooded into Maurits’s classroom, flinging their backpacks onto desks. Maurits stood. “I’m sorry.”
“Oh,” Gina said as he helped her out of the chair and guided her to the door.
Out in the crowded hallway, a group of busty adolescent girls stared at Gina then turned to one another and laughed.
* * *
Kerry McKay is at work on a novel set in Staten Island. Her writing has appeared in Harvard’s Education Next, Your Teen Magazine, Adanna, TheRavensPerch, and other publications. She is a high school reading specialist and holds an MFA in fiction from Fairfield University.