
By Lou-Ellen Barkan
“Guess what?” My sister Lois’s voice was up an octave, so I guessed good news.
“You won the lottery?”
“You’re close. We got a reservation at Premise!”
“You’re kidding” I laughed. “How did you pull that off?”
Premise, New York City’s trendiest restaurant, had just received a five-star review. Instantly, the foodies reached for their phones, looking to score a reservation before the place was old news.
“You guys in?” Lois asked. ” Charlie’s client pulled this off.”
“We’re in. Do we need a bank loan?”
“It’s a freebee. Paid for by the grateful client. Just show up super chic. And, Julia,” she said, dropping to her normal alto. “The client is joining us, so be on your best behavior.”
“I’m devastated,” I said, with a deep sob. “Why would you think I won’t be a perfect lady?”
My cellphone light flashed off.
Ten minutes later, I was deep in the bowels of my closet, also known affectionately as Julia’s Suit Museum. Over thirty years in corporate jobs, I had assembled a world-class collection of suits, pants and skirts, all in my favorite color.
Black.
But the search for the Premise outfit was challenging. If only I had leather. Even faux leather. Unfortunately, the only leather in my closet was my son’s seventh grade bike jacket. He was thirty-five and, fortunately, he had aged better than the jacket. Maybe I should go movie star style. Faded jeans with a hole in the knee, a starchy white shirt and long black cashmere cardigan. Hoopy diamond earrings. A fur coat draped over my shoulders. Sadly, I didn’t own fur or diamonds. And the last time I tried on my jeans, they had shrunk two sizes. My white shirts waiting for someone to iron them before the decade ended.
I kept digging, hopeful that something would spill out. Then I hit paydirt. A black wool skirt clingy enough to be modern and loose enough to allow me to eat. I paired it with a black cashmere turtle neck, added my mother’s triple strand pearl necklace and knee-high suede boots. I added my vintage Burberry trench.
On dinner night, I added Spanx to hold in my middle-aged bulge, checked myself in the mirror and saw a sixty-year-old woman making an effort.
“How do I look?” I asked Michael. “Do I look fat?”
“You look like a sexy nun.” He laughed.
Our Uber driver saw our destination and gave Michael a high five. “You guys won the dinner sweepstakes. Hope someone else is paying.”
At Premise, we were greeted by a beefy, armed guard who checked us in and held the heavy oak doors. As we swept into the sacred space, we were instantly members of the city’s elite. It was intoxicating.
I left my Burberry with a woman whose outfit was worth five times mine and joined Lois and Charlie at the bar where they were talking with another couple, sipping what looked like champagne.
“My sister, Julia,” Lois said, kissing me on both cheeks. “And her husband, Michael. Please meet Alan and Stephanie Leon.”
I looked up at middle aged, bald Alan smiling at me. Stephanie nodded and picked up her drink. Her steel grey hair was cut soccer mom style, short on the sides, long in the back. Her muscular heft implied years of slow weight gain, bulk accentuated by an unfortunate knit dress that highlighted every bulge. Diamond earrings with stones almost as big as her world class boobs were a clever distraction.
After one glass of champagne, I was feeling rather jolly. My Spanx ensured that I looked my size ten personal best, the black sweater set off my mother’s pearls and my haircut was Vogue’s highest rated bob. And, since it wasn’t my party, all I had to do was enjoy the food and take notes to gossip with my BFFs.
“Don’t I know you?” Stephanie looked closely at me. ‘Haven’t we met before?”
“I don’t believe so,” I smiled.
“No,” She said, gripping my arm. “I’m positive we’ve met before. I would recognize that voice anywhere.”
It’s true. I have a distinctive voice, the outcome of a chronic sinus problem. I was debating if I should share this when I noticed my sister’s frightened rabbit look. She was ready to scamper if I said anything to send the evening south. I blinked twice, our private signal that she could relax.
“Of course,” I said. “It’s possible. We’ve lived in the city forever.”
“No,” she shook her head. “We’re suburban. Where did you go to school?”
What followed was the New York geography game. Rapid fire listing of schools, friends, clubs, relatives, friends of relatives, relatives of friends and then finally, the key that opened the door.
“Did you go to camp?” Stephanie asked.
“Camp Bliss.” I said.
“When were you there?”
“Mid-fifties,” No reason to give away my actual age.
“Well, that’s it,” she said with a triumphant snort. “I was there at the same time. You remember me? Stephanie Grassley?”
I put my glass down and stared at her. Oh yes. I definitely remembered Stephanie Grassley, the Second-Place winner in the 1955 Camp Bliss Beauty Pageant.
I was at an uncharacteristic loss for words.
Bliss was my mother’s choice, selected after she interrogated a dozen camp directors on facilities and amenities. Proper bathrooms, mattress quality. A fully staffed infirmary. Counselor to camper ratios. Mandatory buddy system for swimming. Bliss checked all the boxes. Plus, they had a cabin set aside for a beauty parlor with hair dryers. It was indicative of Mom’s priorities that she never asked about athletics.
But on first blush, Bliss wasn’t a bad choice. The owners had matched the inner spring mattresses with professional grade tennis courts and a spectacular lakefront for swimming and diving. We had volleyball, softball, field hockey, riflery, horseback riding, archery and color war. Athletic and competitive by nature, I was picked first for teams and often for captain. Sports was not the problem. On the field, I was a star.
But at dances with the boys’ camp across the lake, not so much.
At twelve, I was at the apogee of an awkward social stage. And notwithstanding my mother’s reassurance that I would soon be the belle of the ball, there was nothing she could do to improve my resemblance to my idols Sandra Dee and Carol Lynley. Unlike me, their body parts aligned, and they were blessed with shiny blond hair and clear skin. Unfortunately, I was always on acne alert. My brown hair and brown eyes were an indeterminate shade. I was convinced that I was a lost cause.
My mother stood firm. “You will grow into your looks,” she said. “Be patient.”
Getting through camp dances was hard enough, but the morning our counselors passed out Beauty Pageant nominating forms, I was furious. The last thing I needed was a contest to compare my looks with the lucky gene crowd. I tore the form up, pushed it into my half-eaten oatmeal, excused myself and went to practice my forehand.
The other campers obediently selected six contestants. One of these was Stephanie Grassley.
On Pageant night, ninety-eight girls, ranging in age from eight to fifteen, met at the steps of the outdoor theater. Two campers were missing. precocious Pageant haters, they stayed behind to run a betting pool. One was a math prodigy who had calculated the odds for each contestant and posted them on her bathroom mirror. By the time the curtain rose, the majority of campers had exhausted their canteen accounts, and the odds did not favor Stephanie.
Campers sat in awe as candidates arrived on the stage, powdered and primped in Pageant style, with bright lipstick and stiff hairdos. Three rounds of competition included bathing suit and ballgown and a personal question.
No one clapped. Envy formed a palpable cloud over the proceeding.
And Stephanie. Oh yes. I remembered her. Long blond hair, clear skin, perfect body, even in the shapeless camp bathing suit. Blue ballgown to match her blue eyes. She came in second.
A moment forever etched in my mind.
After my brief trip down memory lane, I looked in mirror behind the bar and saw Stephanie had aged like a bottle of sour milk. Her skin had curdled into deep ridges, her body shifted to accommodate growing inventory.
And I laughed.
In my size ten, trendy black outfit, I looked, if not like a teenager, definitely like a sexy nun. If Bliss held the Pageant tonight, there is no question who the winner would be.
Mom would have been pleased.
“Of course,” I smiled. “I remember you.”
And right on cue, our table was ready.
“What was that about?” Lois whispered.
“Water under the bridge,” I said.
After the Pageant debacle, Mom found a camp that featured sports, hiking and girls who sang dirty songs around the campfire.
It was heaven.
* * *
Lou-Ellen Barkan, a native New Yorker, lives in the Berkshires where she teaches writing classes, runs a writer’s group and writes short stories for her pleasure and, hopefully, for others. Her two children, six grandchildren, four dogs and three careers have produced enough material for a lifetime of stories, some of which are available at https://www.clippings.me/lebarkan. She holds a BA from Hunter College and an MA from Columbia University.








