‘
By Sarah Burton
AS A NEWBORN
Theo cried with an insistence and tenacity that wore Lila to a stub. He only slept when draped across her chest and even after he slept so soundly she wondered if he was dead, any movement away from the heat and softness of her body elicited screams so loud they woke the rest of the household. Call it colic, call it whatever, the experts at Night Mothers Agency exhausted their resources, threw up their hands, and told Lila to do what she could, so she did. She committed the cardinal sin of the agency. She co-slept.
The agency caught her on the nanny-cam, but by then Cara didn’t care as long as her son slept, which he did if Lila was next to him. We can support any method except this, the agency said. You will have to hire Lila privately if you wish for this to continue, they said. And since Cara had Zoom meetings at 7:30 a.m. three times a week with clients in Germany, she did.
THE ROUTINE
Was then established that Lila arrived at the house at 6:00 p.m.; bathed Theo; fed him his bottle; rocked him in the chair by the window and read him stories as he blinked languidly at the green leaves quivering on the oak; laid him in his crib and sang to him and waited to see if he would cry, which he always did; climbed into the absurdly large crib and lay down next to him, singing until he fell asleep with his head resting against her arm, his lips slightly parted, eyelids fluttering like butterfly wings; removed herself to the trundle she had moved from the side room and placed next to his bed and waited until his next cry, which always came just as she was drifting to sleep.
AN EXAM
Revealed that Theo had anal stenosis, a condition that resolved as he grew and with its resolution his sleep improved. Lila moved the trundle to the side room.
AT AGE ONE
The excruciating pain of gas and bowel movements had been replaced by the need for maternal attention, which grasped his small body just as violently. By the time he was able to walk, his attachment to Lila was so strong that he could not be separated from her even for a moment during her twelve-hour shift. He followed her to the bathroom, the closet, the side room where she kept her original agency-issued overnight bag emblazoned with a logo of a baby resting on a cloud and the initials “NM” held lazily in the baby’s chubby fists.
He seemed to understand that after 6:00 a.m., Lila would not be there for him and he managed the morning transition to his Day Mother without much fuss, but when she arrived back in the evening, his affection and joy were extravagant.
NIGHT TERRORS
Began at age two.
The sunset was a wonder to him: the deepening plum and orange of the sky, the dark green of the large oak tree as the light faded and the stars glimmered between its branches.
But once the light was gone from the sky, the shadows seemed to settle in his soul. He often woke, his eyes wide open, unseeing, dark as though inhabited by the night itself and filled with terror. It took nearly an hour of rocking and singing for him to fall back asleep and then he clutched her with such ferocity that she could not set him down for another hour.
Lila moved the trundle back beside his bed. She rarely slept in it.
EVERY NIGHT
They lay down next to each other, foreheads touching. Sometimes he turned his back toward her so that his whole body rested in the curve of hers. Then he stared out the window into the growing darkness at the oak tree stretching its branches toward him until his eyelids grew heavy.
GRADUATE DEGREES
In early childhood development and education should have prepared her not to develop an improper attachment. Should have prepared her for the intense bonding that occurs between a caregiver and child, especially during the night hours.
WHEN
She crossed the line was impossible to say. She had been inching toward it since the first night she soothed him to sleep, his new, wrinkled fingers grasping her thumb. Perhaps it was when he fell asleep with his palm against her cheek. Or when she started singing and he stopped crying. Or when he clung to her after a night terror.
Perhaps it was the first time he called her “Ny-Ma,” Night Mother.
MY
Little Boy, was how she referred to him to her friends. “My Theo.”
ON HER WALK
To the house every evening, she passed a lilac bush where a pair of rabbits, one big and one small, grazed by the path. They lifted their heads, noses twitching, and watched her walk by. She made up stories for Theo about them—Bunky and Hop—and how they lived in their snug home under the lilac bush and drank hot chocolate and made cookies for their friends and ate carrots left for them by a mysterious little boy who had a secret garden that could be entered only by flying over the wall with a gigantic kite.
What about on days when there’s no wind? He asked, now three and wise about things like how kites need wind to fly. She said the little boy’s mother blew and blew until she made a great wind and he could fly the kite. Theo turned away from her and lay still for a long time. Finally, he whispered that Cara didn’t like flying kites. I wish . . . he said, but left the wish suspended.
CARA
Saw how devoted Theo was to Lila and decided it was time for him to sleep on his own. In December, a few days after his fourth birthday, Cara informed Lila that it would be her last night with him.
Lila cried as she turned down Theo’s bed, wiping the tears on the forest green lounge shirt she wore because it was his favorite color.
HE CAME
Into the room like a tornado after his mother broke the news, anger and fear and sadness propelling his small body with a furious energy. He refused to cooperate with Lila’s bath time instructions, throwing himself on the floor, his limbs a windmill beating the ground. Once she got him into the bath, more water exited the tub than remained inside. When his energy was exhausted, he resorted to going limp, forcing her to hold his arm straight while pulling one sleeve on, then the other. One pant leg, then the other.
At story time he pulled all the books off the shelf and lay on top of them and refused to move so she lay down next to him and they stayed there until he began to sob quietly and then flung himself into her arms and they cried together.
He clung to the stuffed rabbits she had given him for his birthday (one big and one small) and stared at the bare old oak and the snow sparkling on the lawn like sugar crystals while she struggled through his bedtime story and tears dripped onto his sandy brown hair.
LILA
Slept during the daytime. At night she sat awake, watching the sun set, the stars glimmer, the moon rise, the darkness deepen.
She thought about Theo in his big bed. How she should have sleep trained him. Should have been firm and rational when the nightmares came instead of rocking him back to sleep. Should have let him learn to comfort himself. Shouldn’t have gotten so attached to him. Shouldn’t have loved him.
FEBRUARY
Began with a snowstorm that knocked out the power for several days. When it was restored, Lila’s phone had several missed calls from Cara. She called back immediately.
Cara said Theo’s preschool teachers were concerned about his daytime fatigue, clinginess, tantrums, lack of interest in playing with others. The preschool therapist suggested that Theo be allowed to stay home with a nanny. It might suit his temperament better, she said. She said it needed to be with someone to whom he could develop a healthy attachment.
The blood in Lila’s ears pounded so hard she almost didn’t hear Cara’s question. Would Lila be interested in being a live-in nanny? At least through preschool and Kindergarten, maybe longer? There was a guest house on the property, just behind the house, she would get weekends and vacation time, could she start next week? Lila said yes and kept saying yes and finally stopped listening. Her mind wandered to a lilac bush; two rabbits, one big and one small; a little boy running with a kite string in his hand; and a kite soaring up up up.
* * *
Sarah Gane Burton is a freelance writer living in Michigan with her husband, two children, and a dog. Her work has appeared in Medical Literary Messenger and Third Wednesday.








