
By Ella Torres
She put herself in that position. She had loved a man who didn’t know how to love. Really? Really, Cleo. We went over this a thousand times already. She reassured herself as she stuffed the expensive Ralph Lauren winter vest he’d gotten her two Christmases ago into a cardboard box full of other expensive clothes she’d never have occasion to wear now.
Cleo was twenty-five, broke and broken-hearted, and homeless, well practically homeless (she did not yet have a home) in New York City, the city she moved to seven years ago thinking she would make it as an abstract expressionist. Instead, she’d made it as a cautionary tale.
She looked at the high-ceiling NoMad apartment she’d shared with Eric for the past year and a tear fell down her face before she could stop it. This was never home, she whispered to herself, pressing the elevator button like it might argue back. Eric had never wanted her to move in. She’d pushed for it after two years together, and he’d finally said yes with the enthusiasm of someone agreeing to a root canal.
Eric wasn’t cruel. Not text-book cruel but wallstreet jerk cruel, sure. He’d surprise her with flowers sometimes, daisies, her favorite and cook her dinner when he was able to get home from the office early. He’d watch Love Is Blind with her and tell her how she’d be the prettiest contestant, clearly not getting the show’s purpose. But Cleo didn’t care, all this flattered her. Sometimes Eric really saw her, made her feel like the only person in the world. Those moments were heroin.
But Eric had turned thirty this year, meaning he had a new five-year plan and she wasn’t a part of it. She found the ring. His grandmother’s. Not for her. Not for anyone with a face yet. Just a placeholder in his timeline, a girl-shaped space waiting to be filled. The position could be filled by anyone who checked the boxes: finance girl, maybe a doctor, someone whose family summered somewhere with a capital S. Someone whose mother hadn’t worked the cosmetics counter at Macy’s. Someone who understood which fork to use without watching everyone else first. For Eric, marriage wasn’t about love it was a line item on a spreadsheet, scheduled between “make VP” and “buy property in the Hamptons.”
Cleo was the intermission. The warm body in his bed while he built his career, the convenient plus-one who didn’t demand too much while he wasn’t ready to look for someone serious. She kept his apartment from feeling empty, laughed at his colleagues’ jokes at dinner parties, and never complained when he worked through weekends. She was easy. Undemanding. Temporary. And she’d mistaken all of that for love.
She hailed a cab she couldn’t afford down to her older cousin’s condo in Tribeca, where she would be staying for the week. Minnie, who worked as an analyst at JP Morgan and hadn’t texted Cleo since someone’s wedding in July, had responded within minutes: “Of course you can stay. Stay as long as you need.” Which Cleo translated to mean two weeks, possibly three if she kept the crying to acceptable levels.
As the cab turned onto Prince Street, SoHo spreading out like a promise she’d almost forgotten. The cast-iron buildings with their fire escapes like black lace, the gallery windows glowing warm against the November cold. This was the New York she’d fallen for at eighteen, before Eric, before she’d learned to make herself small. She used to walk these streets for hours, ducking into galleries she couldn’t afford to buy from, sketching in cafes, believing she’d make something that mattered. As she went past the street she loved she realized, Eric had made her second, but the city had made her first. She’d loved New York before she’d loved him, and she’d love it after.
The cab parked outside Minnie’s apartment, a high rise with floor-to-ceiling windows and the kind of lobby where people said “good evening” instead of “hey.” The building had a gym Cleo would never use and a doorman who looked like he’d been hired specifically to make people like Cleo feel underdressed.
The meter hit $47 she didn’t have.
Instead of panicking she gave the driver a smile.
She’d figure it out. She always did.
* * *
Ella Torres is a Brazilian writer and translator and a graduate of Barnard College, where she earned a degree in English and Creative Writing. She writes editorials, fiction, and poetry, and is currently pursuing an MFA in fiction at The New School. Her work has appeared in Broad Ripple Review, Litbop, and other publications. Her upcoming novel, The Midnight Saints, won the New 2 The Scene Novel Competition 2025.








