A Memoir by Johanna Elattar

The television in our living room showed a unicorn that summer—a pearlescent creature with a single, spiraling horn—destined for Madison Square Garden. I was eleven, and unlike the adults around me, I still believed in the possibility of a miracle. I didn’t know about surgical grafts or the grim theater of animal acts. I only knew that I wanted to see it.

My father’s youngest brother was staying with us then, the youngest of my grandmother’s five sons. When I asked him to take me, he answered without thinking. He was lost in his own thoughts.

“Yeah, okay. I’ll get the tickets,” he said.

A week passed. The circus was moving closer, the ads getting louder. “Did you get them?” I asked.

“They’re in the mail,” he told me, his voice flat and practiced. “Any day now.”

That was the start of the ritual. Every afternoon, I’d leave the apartment and head for the lobby. The Brooklyn heat was a physical weight, smelling of hot asphalt and the briny ghost of the harbor. I’d stand before the bank of dented metal mailboxes, my small key slick with sweat.

The sound of the key in the lock was a hopeful click. The sound of the box swinging open was a hollow clack.

Clack. Utility bills for my mother. Clack. A circular for the supermarket. Clack. Empty.

In those first weeks, the key felt different in my hand — lighter, charged with what might be waiting on the other side. I’d take the stairs fast, my heart already moving ahead of my feet. Every afternoon was a small beginning, a door that hadn’t been opened yet.

By July, the “any day now” had become a mantra. I’d ask him on Mondays, then Wednesdays, then only on Fridays. He never changed his story. He never looked guilty. He just kept promising the arrival of an envelope that didn’t exist.

By August, something shifted. The key didn’t feel like possibility anymore. It was just metal. I knew the box was empty before I even turned it. I could feel the vacuum of it through my palm. Yet I didn’t stop. I didn’t confront him. I didn’t ask why the mail was taking six weeks to travel from Midtown to our hallway. I just kept the ritual alive, a silent, daily pilgrimage to a metal box.

I kept the ember of expectation burning because I refused to be like the people who surrounded me—the ones who had allowed the world to break their wonder until they were as hollow as that mailbox. I went down every day because I chose to believe in the unicorn, even after I stopped believing in my uncle.

One evening I was alone in the living room when the commercial came on. The same music, the same pearlescent horn — but the words had changed. Last week in New York City. I sat with that for a moment. The circus was gone. The window had closed while I was still checking the mail. I got up, went downstairs, and turned the key anyway.

Clack.

I didn’t tell anyone what I’d seen. There was no one to tell.

The day before school started, I went down one last time. I couldn’t have explained why. The ritual had become its own reason by then — separate from tickets, separate from unicorns, separate from anything he had or hadn’t done. I just went. Because I was the one who went.

I stood before the metal box. There was nothing left of the feeling that used to carry me down those stairs — no flutter, no forward lean, no small voice saying maybe. Just the key in my hand and the knowledge of what I was about to find. But I turned it anyway.

Clack.

Nothing but a supermarket circular. No tickets. No miracle.

I stood there holding the circular, the paper soft from the heat. The unicorn on the television, the goat with the bone-graft horn, and the man who had promised me tickets — they were the same thing. A performance of something that wasn’t real.

I locked the box and walked back up the stairs. I passed him without a word. He didn’t look up, and for the first time, I didn’t need him to.

                                                                  *   *   *

Johanna Elattar is a professional writer and Pushcart Prize nominee whose investigative reporting on Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women (MMIW) is featured in the Oxford University Press textbook Race and Racisms (4th Edition) and Unheard Voices Magazine. Her creative nonfiction has appeared in Santa Fe Literary Review, and Yellow Arrow Publishing. She was a finalist for the Diana Woods Memorial Award at Lunch Ticket (Antioch University), where she was shortlisted by Michelle Tea.